On November 14, 2004, there was an “historic” occasion when four professed evangelicals, the Pastor General of the Worldwide Church of God, a Mormon author and BYU professor, and a contemporary Christian music singer spoke, preached, and sang with thousands of Mormons and evangelicals in the Mormon Tabernacle at Salt Lake City, Utah. This occasion was called “An Evening of Friendship.”The event was organized by a group of churches called Striving Together, represented by its director, Greg Johnson. Ravi Zacharias, a popular evangelical Christian apologist, preached for an hour. Before he spoke, however, President Richard Mouw of Fuller Theological Seminary provided the opening remarks, beginning with a forthright “apology” and admission of evangelicals’ “sinning” against Mormons through the last century and a half. He described the recent opportunities evangelicals and Mormons have engaged in: “important matters of public morality;” “dialogues” that are “frank but friendly exchanges about important faith topics;” and now their meeting together this night, evangelicals “experiencing the gracious hospitality of the LDS leadership, who have welcomed us all into this meeting place.”
Many evangelicals have responded to this “Evening of Friendship” by comparing it to Paul’s preaching of the gospel to the Athenians at the Areopagus in Acts 17. Such a comparison seems to give a biblical basis for evangelicals participating in this both ecumenical and inter-faith “event.” But is this a true comparison? Were Mouw and Zacharias really preaching the gospel in the same way Paul did? Are Mormons Christians after all? Can Christians work together with Mormons?